BMW May Bring Physical Buttons Back, Did Touchscreens Go Too Far?

World NewsLeave a Comment on BMW May Bring Physical Buttons Back, Did Touchscreens Go Too Far?

BMW May Bring Physical Buttons Back, Did Touchscreens Go Too Far?

“BMW 5 series interior.” by Rob Ellis’ is licensed under CC BY 2.0

Car makers have been ditching switches and knobs for large touchscreens and digital buttons for years. BMW has taken this approach with its new Neue Klasse cars, which feature cabins that appear clean and modern. But not everyone is sold on the idea that all the stuff you need to drive a car can be managed on a touchscreen.

Fortunately for the traditionalists, it seems that BMW is open to some reconsideration. The makers have opened the door for customer responses to their vehicle design, hinting that a choice of climate control buttons, along with controls on the steering wheel, could make a return in the years to come. While BMW has not announced concrete plans, the company has made it clear that it’s listening.

Elegant BMW car interior showcasing navigation screen, speedometer, and steering wheel.
Photo by Ingo Joseph on Pexels

1. BMW Is Open to Bringing Physical Controls Back

BMW’s Neue Klasse design language has upended most of BMW’s traditional cabin layouts. To reduce clutter, several of the brand’s characteristic knobs, switches and buttons have been swapped out for touch-sensitive interfaces and screens. The effects are visually clean cabins but the move also sparks questions over how well BMW drivers will be able to reach controls safely.

What BMW Is Willing to Reconsider:

  • Physical controls could return
  • Customer feedback remains important
  • Touchscreens are not the only option
  • Future designs may be adjusted
  • Driver convenience remains a priority

What’s interesting about the company’s stance is that BMW has been investing in this digital interior approach for some time. Rather than forcing all drivers to use touch and voice controls, its executives have realized that one group of customers might prefer something else. That doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s a carbon copy of the dashboard, but BMW clearly isn’t fighting tooth and nail to go all-digital.

2. Neue Klasse Models Have Introduced a Digital Cabin

Instead of the cluster of traditional instruments typically seen in earlier versions, BMW Neue Klasse models now have a more radical config. Instead of a cluster of traditional instruments traditionally positioned behind the steering wheel, drivers will now be greeted with a display that’s projected out across the lower part of the windscreen, and can be tailored to suit a driver’s preference.

Inside the Neue Klasse Interior:

  • 17.9-inch central touchscreen
  • Windshield-based information display
  • Optional passenger display screen
  • Fewer traditional dashboard switches
  • Cleaner, digital cabin layout

That’s a pretty dramatic shift from the automotive benchmark established by BMW and other driver-centric automakers, where knobs and switches rule the cabin, often alongside the physical instruments on the dashboard. The digital display design is perhaps the most striking example of that, as not only does it give the cabin a techie look, but it forces owners to use the screen when they might have used a lever or switch instead.

3. BMW Says Customer Feedback Could Influence Future Designs

Claudia Maier, BMW’s digital technology manager for the Neue Klasse models, told Australia’s Carsales in a briefing from the international launch of the new BMW 3 Series and i3. “BMW is feeling comfortable with the approach to sharing information with drivers. But the company is also cognizant that it’s listening to the customers is as important. She said the company feels that the feedback that they are getting from customers helps them to understand the needs and influence their digital technology.”

What Maier’s Comments Tell Us:

  • BMW values customer opinions
  • Digital design remains its focus
  • Strong demand will be considered
  • Interior changes are not ruled out
  • Future controls remain open-ended

Maier pointed to climate controls and the steering wheel buttons as areas where physical buttons could be reintroduced. This is because those controls are used while the car is in motion so having dedicated buttons that are quick to reach and easily operated is beneficial. One example is a heated seat that would be easier to operate with a physical button than scrolling through various menus on the touchscreen. BMW has not said which controls will be coming back.

a close up of a door handle on a car
Photo by Mustafa Fatemi on Unsplash

4. Some Physical Controls Have Survived the Digital Change

It is very innovative but there is still lots of physical controls. Even the all-electric BMWs will have the same indicator and wipers stalks. There is a physical volume control so that you can have a sound to grips with. The demisting and window switches are on the door, so no digital replacement of buttons yet. For the new BMW you will still find a lot of BMW DNA in this Neue class.

Controls Still Found in the Cabin:

  • Traditional indicator stalks
  • Physical windscreen wiper stalks
  • Dedicated volume controller
  • Separate demisting switches
  • Door-mounted window switches

The other hardware indicates that not everything in the new BMW is focused on touch. There are still tangible controls for some functions, even in a cabin where everything has been designed around touch. However, the removal of the rotary iDrive controller will be keenly felt by BMW drivers who have been used to the classic feel of their control systems.

Modern luxury car interior featuring a high-tech dashboard and sleek design.
Photo by Redyar Rzgar on Pexels

5. Younger Buyers Are Influencing BMW’s Digital Approach

The adoption of touch and voice controls by BMW is also said to be related to customer adoption habits. According to Car Expert, BMW Group Australia CEO Vikram Pawah said that up until 25 years ago most cars had a single CD player with a handful of buttons. Now many customers aged 45 and under are used to touchscreen and voice assistant controls.

Why BMW Is Looking at Younger Buyers:

  • Digital habits are changing
  • Younger buyers use voice controls
  • Touchscreen interaction feels familiar
  • Customers expect quick responses
  • Cars reflect wider social trends

The technology that is integrated into the car is not isolated from the world in which it exists, added Pawah. As technology grows increasingly prominent in everyday life, manufacturers should understand what that means to someone behind the wheel. It is one reason BMW has so heavily invested in digital interfaces. But, as Pahaw is quick to point out, the preferences of young buyers may not be representative of all customers.

6. BMW Is Investing in Voice Control and Artificial Intelligence

BMW is building up more sophisticated voice control. The Neue Klasse iX3 is equipped with a cloud-based, intelligent voice assistant, which is found on Amazon’s Alexa+. It relies on the large-language technology of artificial intelligence and enables the driver to put in a request in a more natural way without navigating through many menus.

The Growing Role of Voice Technology:

  • Amazon Alexa+ powers BMW’s assistant
  • Natural language requests are supported
  • AI could simplify vehicle controls
  • Mercedes is exploring voice interaction
  • Volkswagen has integrated chtgpt

Using your voice can be convenient on the go. For example, for example, you can ask your system to play a certain tune on your Spotify music library, or you can use it to input a destination on your GPS screen. This way you don’t have to take your eyes off the road to press a button. However, voice doesn’t always win: It might be faster and more reliable to use a physical temperature dial or a dedicated button, for example, when the driver is only trying to make a slight adjustment to climate control without actually having to speak to the system.

Explore the sleek interior and advanced dashboard of the Ferrari 458 Speciale.
Photo by Jae Park on Pexels

7. Other Carmakers Are Bringing Physical Buttons Back

BMW isn’t the only brand second-guessing the adoption of more tablet-like cab interiors: Ferrari has reacted to criticisms of the SF90’s capacitive touch wheel controls by installing real clicks on the 2027 Amalfi. Physical controls are making their way into the more mainstream forms as well Volkswagen’s new ID. Tiguan, that will replace the ID.4, is on track to make its debut in the UK next year and will feature physical buttons in the cabin. The Golf GTI and Cupra Born have brought tactile switches back to the steering wheels.

Physical Controls Are Returning Across Brands:

  • Ferrari adds clickable steering buttons
  • SF90 owners get retrofit options
  • Volkswagen ID.Tiguan gets physical buttons
  • Golf GTI restores tactile switches
  • Mercedes adds steering wheel buttons

They are also fitting physical buttons to the steering wheel of its electric GLC. Audi, meanwhile, is coming up with similar tactile layouts for its new A4 E-tron and Q7 E-tron. These developments mean that firms are finally starting to see the point of not having everything digital, and a contemporary interior can look uncluttered and high tech while still placing commonly accessed controls within easy reach.

silver and black car air vent
Photo by Olav Tvedt on Unsplash

8. Research and Safety Rules Support Physical Switchgear

Market research indicates that a significant percentage of drivers have a preference for conventional car control systems. According to a survey published by Auto Pacific and mentioned by The Drive, 48 per cent of automobile buyers preferred buttons and dials for their in-cabin controls over touchscreen interfaces, even as 60 per cent liked the design of the digital displays themselves. Customers don’t appear to be opposed to digital, they want digital 50/50.

What the Research and Regulations Show:

  • 48% prefer dials or buttons
  • 60% like digital display styling
  • Physical controls require engineering work
  • China has proposed new requirements
  • Euro NCAP supports essential buttons

Government bodies are taking notice as well. In China, the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology has suggested legislation mandating that must-have vehicle controls have physical buttons starting in 2027. Europe’s auto safety authorities have also begun to shift the focus of safety assessments toward tactile input; the 2026 Euro NCAP test summary announced “Buttons return for essential functions.” BMW’s second-generation iX3 scored a perfect 100 percent against the latest requirements for crucial physical controls, indicating that BMW’s existing controls checked that box.

9. BMW Will Keep Apple CarPlay Ultra Out of Its Dashboard

That leaves BMW willing to be flexible on physical controls, but has set a line for the software that runs inside its vehicle. BMW has already stated that it would rule out Apple Car Play Ultra, which would give Apple’s system full access to a larger part of the dashboard than traditional smartphone mirroring, including the instrument clusters and controls such as heating and air conditioning.

BMW’s Position on Smartphone Integration:

  • Apple CarPlay Ultra is ruled out
  • BMW wants to protect vehicle data
  • Interior software remains under its control
  • Standard Apple CarPlay will remain
  • Android Auto is still supported

However, that won’t delete the fundamental wireless Apple Car Play or Android Auto. Owners will continue to be able to link up their smartphones to the centre screen and launch any supported mobile apps without needing a wire. The difference is that BMW is more than happy to enable conventional phone mirroring, but does not want an outside operating system to take over all or most parts of the car experience.

black BMW steering wheel
Photo by Jonas Morgner on Unsplash

10. A Return to Physical Buttons May Take Time

It’s great that BMW is open to hearing what customers would like. This is a little difficult to do when you’re working with an existing dashboard though. The controls for the driver are quite close to the main interior trim panels, wiring and even safety systems. It’s even changing things like this can be complicated and costly to do, as many revisions to a present design can be quite complicated.

What Drivers Can Expect Next:

  • No immediate button comeback confirmed
  • Dashboard changes require extensive engineering
  • Future generations offer more opportunities
  • Neue Klasse rollout is continuing
  • Customer feedback remains under consideration

That is the key factor BMW has left the door open for a rebalancing of the interior, with executives saying that physical controls might be introduced again if enough customers demand them. And so there is the potential for a future car interior that features the high-tech displays and information technology of today’s modern vehicles, along with their smart voice commands, alongside the intuitive, physical controls that still appeal to so many car drivers.

John Faulkner is Road Test Editor at Clean Fleet Report. He has more than 30 years’ experience branding, launching and marketing automobiles. He has worked with General Motors (all Divisions), Chrysler (Dodge, Jeep, Eagle), Ford and Lincoln-Mercury, Honda, Mazda, Mitsubishi, Nissan and Toyota on consumer events and sales training programs. His interest in automobiles is broad and deep, beginning as a child riding in the back seat of his parent’s 1950 Studebaker. He is a journalist member of the Motor Press Guild and Western Automotive Journalists.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top